Report a Claim
It is our desire to make the claims process as fast and easy as possible. Following is a list for you to contact your claims adjuster directly to aid in this process. We are here for you and that is never more evident than in the claims process. Contacting the carrier directly will expedite the claims process, but we are here to help. Please contact us with any questions or concerns you have in the claims process.
| Carrier | Claims Phone |
| Brethren Mutual | 800-621-4264 (Monday to Friday, 8:00 am to 4:30 pm) After hours and weekends: 877-300-0864 Glass: 877-646-8963 |
| Cincinnati Insurance | 877-242-2544 (24/7) |
| Donegal | 800-877-9006 (24/7) Glass: 866-439-4527 |
| Kemper | 800-353-6737 (auto, home and commercial auto) |
| Millers Mutual | 800-745-4555 |
| Mutual Benefit | 800-290-6361 Glass: 800-232-8315 |
| Penn National | 800-766-2245 Glass: 866-683-9808 Workers’ comp: 800-374-4990 |
| Progressive | 800-776-4737 (personal and commercial auto) |
| Selective | 866-455-9969 Flood: 877-348-0552 |
| State Auto | 877-722-5246 Glass: 888-504-4527 |
| Travelers | Personal claims: 800-252-4633 Business claims: report online Business auto glass: 800-238-6225 |
| Glass: windshield and other auto glass claims. Workers’ comp: workplace injury claims. Each carrier name links to that carrier’s claims page. | |
